MIT: A Classic Example of the Power of what I call “The University-Financial Complex”

January 14, 2013


Dan Kennedy

Assistant Professor, School of Journalism at Northeastern University


The suicide of Internet activist Aaron Swartz has prompted a wave of revulsion directed at U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz, who was seeking to put him in prison for 35 years on charges that he illegally downloaded millions of academic articles.

Swartz, 26, who helped develop the RSS standard and was a co-founder of Reddit, was “driven to the edge by what a decent society would only call bullying,” wrote his friend and lawyer Lawrence Lessig. “I get wrong,” Lessig added. “But I also get proportionality. And if you don’t get both, you don’t deserve to have the power of the United States government behind you.”

By Sunday evening, nearly 9,000 people had signed an online petition asking President Obama to remove Ortiz. Swartz’s family released a statement that said in part: “Aaron’s death is not simply a personal tragedy. It is the product of a criminal justice system rife with intimidation and prosecutorial overreach.”

Ortiz’s vindictiveness toward Swartz may have seemed shocking given that even the victim of Swartz’s alleged offense — the academic publisher JSTOR — did not wish to press charges. But it was no surprise to those of us who have been observing Ortiz’s official conduct as the top federal prosecutor in Boston.

Notwithstanding the anger that has been unleashed at Ortiz following Aaron Swartz’s death, she should not be regarded as an anomaly. As the noted civil-liberties lawyer Harvey Silverglate points out in his 2009 book, Three Felonies a Day: How the Feds Target the Innocent, federal prosecutors have been given vague, broad powers that have led to outrages against justice across the country.

“Wrongful prosecution of innocent conduct that is twisted into a felony charge has wrecked many an innocent life and career,” writes Silverglate, a friend and occasional collaborator. “Whole families have been devastated, as have myriad relationships and entire companies.”

Ortiz may now find that her willingness to use those vast powers against Swartz could have a harmful effect on her future.

As a Latina and as a tough law-and-order Democrat, she has been seen as a hot political property in Massachusetts. In 2011 the Boston Globe Magazine named her its “Bostonian of the Year.” She recently told the Boston Herald she was not interested in running for either the U.S. Senate or governor. But that doesn’t mean she couldn’t be persuaded. Now, though, she may be regarded as damaged goods.

Those who are mourning the death of Aaron Swartz should keep in mind that he had long struggled with depression. Blaming his suicide on Carmen Ortiz is unfair.

Nevertheless, the case she was pursuing against Swartz was wildly disproportionate, and illustrated much that is wrong with our system of justice. Nothing good can come from his death. But at the very least it should prompt consideration of why such brutality has become a routine part of the American system of justice.

Follow Dan Kennedy on Twitter:

Related News On Huffington Post:

NewYorker Everyone Interesting is a Felon: Tim Wu (@superwuster) on how the legal system failed Aaron Swartz– and us:

latimes Feds drop charges against late Internet activist Aaron Swartz

thedailybeast Shame on @BarackObama & Eric Holder for allowing justice to run amok against people like Aaron Swartz #ThoughtCrime

emilybazelon I can’t match the greater eloquence of others, but here’s my rant about the egregious overcharging of Aaron Swartz

57 minutes ago from web
businessinsider Now 16,000 People Are Asking President Obama To Fire Aaron Swartz’s Prosecutor by @Julie188

sarahcuda On the overzealous prosecution of Aaron Swartz via@pandodaily

gapersblock Vintage Aaron Swartz Interview: Fourteen-year-old Aaron Swartz was interviewed on WBEZ’s “Eight Forty-Eight” in…

InformationWeek Anonymous Hacks MIT In Aaron Swartz Tribute

annamasera Per il #pdftribute ad #Aaron_Swartz compilate @la_stampa (Grazie @berny scusa urgenza ma importante pubblicare subito)

annamasera (Grazie @berny scusa urgenza ma importante pubblicare subito) Per il #pdftribute ad #Aaron_Swartz compilate @la _stampa

DavidAbiker Curieux cette offre publicitaire en plein milieu d’un article du Monde évoquant la disparition de #AaronSwartz

2 hours ago from web
HuffPostPol Aaron Swartz’s lawyer: Prosecutor wanted a “juicy” case for publicity

drew The Aaron Swartz Hacking Case Has Been Dismissed By The US District Court by @johnbiggs

2 hours ago from web
TechCrunch The Aaron Swartz Hacking Case Has Been Dismissed By The US District Court by @johnbiggs

alexia Aaron Swartz, Asking For Help, 119 Days Ago

GottaLaff RT @JohnWDean: TRAGICALLY LATE,wrong reason @justiacom RT@arstechnica: Govt formally drops chges against Aaron Swartz

LegalCerebral Aaron Swartz’s Suicide Prompts MIT Soul Searching

laurenonizzle Academics pay #PDFtribute to activist Aaron Swartz:

YourAnonNews BREAKING: CHICAGO – #WBC to protest Aaron Swartz’s funeral. #Anonymous #AnonFamily #AnonHive


  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 1
  • View FAQ

Post CommentPreview Comment

To reply to a Comment: Click “Reply” at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.

Share your Comment:

Post to Facebook.
Post to Blogger.
Post to Twitter.
Post to WordPress.
Post to TypePad.
Post to Tumblr.
View All


Recency  |





Dedicated Truther!
6 minutes ago ( 5:53 PM)

Remove United States District Attorney Carmen Ortiz from office for overreach in the case of Aaron Swartz.

It is too late to do anything for Aaron Swartz, but the who used the powers granted to them by their office to hound him into a position where he was facing a ruinous trial, life in prison and the ignominy and shame of being a convicted felon; for an alleged crime that the supposed victims did not wish to prosecute.A prosecutor who does not understand proportionality and who regularly uses the threat of unjust and overreaching charges to extort plea bargains from defendants regardless of their guilt is a danger to the life and liberty of anyone who might cross her path.

18,000 signatures now on this petition – need 25,000!


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: